<img alt="" src="https://secure.7-companycompany.com/795175.png" style="display:none;">
Let's Talk

10 Common Mistakes Amazon Sellers Make and How to Avoid Them

10 Common Mistakes Amazon Sellers Make and How to Avoid Them

Navigating the competitive landscape of Amazon selling can be challenging, especially for new sellers. Many make advertising mistakes that hinder their success. To help you avoid these pitfalls, let’s explore key takeaways.


1. Overlooking Listing Competitiveness

The most important factor by far is ensuring that your listing is competitive. Whether you are focusing on rankings or immediate visibility through Pay-Per-Click (PPC) advertising, your listing must stand out. Initially, PPC is a great way to get visibility and traffic, as it can place you at the top of the first page from day one without running a rankings campaign. However, this visibility only converts to sales if your listing is attractive.

Key Steps to Enhance Competitiveness:

  • Aggressive Pricing: Be strategic with your pricing. Offering competitive prices can attract more buyers.
  • Appealing Offers: Consider adding bonuses or special deals to make your offer more appealing.
  • Strong Creatives: Invest in high-quality images, videos, and "as seen in" badges to build social proof and maximize conversion rates.

2. Focusing on Rankings Without Enough Reviews

A common mistake is trying to rank for keywords where your product isn’t competitive. For instance, if your competition has thousands of reviews and you have only a few, ranking alone won't ensure sustained visibility or sales. In the beginning, you might see your product rank well, only to drop off quickly. This happens because consumers tend to choose products with a high number of reviews, even if your product is slightly better or cheaper.

Review Threshold Guidelines:

  • 20-30 Competitor Reviews: Aim for at least 10 reviews.
  • 100-900 Competitor Reviews: You need around 100 reviews.
  • Over 1000 Competitor Reviews: Strive for a comparable number of reviews to be competitive.

3. Relying Too Heavily on One Marketing Channel

While leveraging social media platforms like TikTok can be highly effective, it's risky to rely too heavily on one channel, especially with the potential for regulatory changes. Diversify your marketing efforts to avoid sudden disruptions.

Effective Marketing Strategies:

  • Social Media Influencers: Be cautious when engaging with influencers for reviews. Avoid those flagged by Amazon for leaving numerous reviews on various products.
  • Micro-Influencers: Target individuals with smaller followings (under 1000 followers). These "pseudo-influencers" often have a more genuine influence within their close-knit communities.
  • Amazon Vine: While Vine can provide up to 30 reviews, be aware of its pitfalls. Vine reviewers tend to be more critical, and the reviews can take an unpredictable amount of time to accumulate. Additionally, Vine reviews often weigh more heavily and can impact your overall rating significantly.

4. Neglecting Long-Term Review Strategies

Long-term success on Amazon requires a steady stream of positive reviews. Simply relying on initial reviews or short-term campaigns isn't enough. You need a sustainable strategy to garner positive feedback continuously.

Building a Long-Term Review Funnel:

  • Product Packaging and Inserts: Use these to guide customers to leave reviews. Include a call-to-action that encourages satisfied customers to share their experience.
  • Customer Interaction: Engage with your customers post-purchase. Provide excellent customer service and follow-up to ensure satisfaction, prompting them to leave positive reviews.

5. Poor Keyword Research

Effective keyword research is crucial for Amazon SEO and PPC campaigns. Many sellers make the mistake of targeting broad or highly competitive keywords without considering long-tail keywords that could drive more targeted traffic with less competition.

Tips for Effective Keyword Research:

  • Use Tools: Utilize keyword research tools like Helium 10, Jungle Scout, or Amazon's own keyword suggestions.
  • Competitor Analysis: Analyze the keywords your competitors are ranking for and identify gaps where you can position your product.
  • Long-Tail Keywords: Focus on long-tail keywords that are specific to your product. These keywords often have lower competition and can attract more qualified buyers.

6. Ineffective PPC Campaign Management

PPC campaigns can be a powerful tool for driving traffic and sales, but many sellers fail to manage them effectively. Common mistakes include setting and forgetting campaigns, not optimizing bids, and ignoring data.

Best Practices for PPC Campaign Management:

  • Regular Monitoring: Continuously monitor and adjust your campaigns based on performance data.
  • Bid Optimization: Adjust your bids to ensure you're getting the most out of your budget. Lower bids on underperforming keywords and increase bids on high-converting ones.
  • Negative Keywords: Use negative keywords to avoid wasting ad spend on irrelevant searches.
  • A/B Testing: Conduct A/B tests on ad copy and images to determine what resonates best with your audience.

7. Ignoring Amazon's Guidelines and Policies

Compliance with Amazon's guidelines and policies is essential to avoid account suspension or other penalties. Sellers sometimes overlook these rules, leading to costly mistakes.

Key Guidelines to Follow:

  • Review Policies: Ensure you understand and comply with Amazon’s review policies. Avoid incentivizing reviews in ways that violate these guidelines.
  • Listing Guidelines: Adhere to Amazon's product listing guidelines, including accurate descriptions, appropriate categories, and compliant images.
  • Performance Metrics: Maintain high performance metrics such as order defect rate, cancellation rate, and late shipment rate to avoid account issues.

8. Inadequate Inventory Management

Running out of stock or overstocking can both hurt your Amazon business. Effective inventory management is crucial to maintain a balance and ensure continuous sales.

Inventory Management Tips:

  • Use Inventory Tools: Leverage inventory management tools to keep track of your stock levels.
  • Forecasting: Use sales data to forecast demand and plan your inventory accordingly.
  • Avoid Stockouts: Plan your restocks well in advance to avoid running out of stock, which can negatively impact your rankings and sales.
  • Manage Overstock: Avoid overstocking, which can lead to high storage fees and cash flow issues.

9. Neglecting Customer Service

Providing excellent customer service can significantly impact your reviews and seller rating. Neglecting customer service can lead to negative reviews and a poor seller rating.

Customer Service Best Practices:

  • Timely Responses: Respond to customer inquiries and issues promptly.
  • Resolve Issues: Address customer complaints and issues effectively to turn potential negative experiences into positive ones.
  • Follow-Up: Send follow-up emails to ensure customer satisfaction and encourage positive reviews.

10. Ignoring Competitor Analysis

Regularly analyzing your competitors is crucial for staying competitive on Amazon. Many sellers neglect to keep an eye on their competition, missing out on opportunities to improve their own listings and strategies.

Competitor Analysis Tips:

  • Monitor Competitor Listings: Regularly check your competitors' listings to see what they are doing well and where they are lacking.
  • Pricing Strategies: Keep an eye on competitors' pricing strategies and adjust your prices accordingly to stay competitive.
  • Customer Feedback: Read competitors' reviews to understand what customers like or dislike about their products and use this information to improve your own offerings.


Avoiding these common advertising mistakes can set you on the path to success as an Amazon seller. By ensuring your listing is competitive, strategically gathering reviews, diversifying your marketing channels, managing your PPC campaigns effectively, adhering to Amazon's guidelines, managing your inventory well, providing excellent customer service, and staying on top of competitor analysis, you'll be better equipped to thrive in the competitive Amazon marketplace. Remember, the goal is not just to rank well initially but to maintain that ranking through consistent and strategic efforts.


We Can Help!

Phelps UNITED is here to provide expert guidance on your Amazon selling strategy and brand advertising tips, explore our website to learn more.

Recent Posts

Riding the Wave of Emerging E-commerce Trends
Decoding Amazon's Top Categories: Insider Tips for Sellers
10 Common Mistakes Amazon Sellers Make and How to Avoid Them
Advantages of Amazon's Ships in Product Packaging (SIPP) Program
Tapping into Opportunity: Amazon Sellers and the Pet Product Realm


Amazon Tips
eCommerce Strategies
Amazon Seller
Shopping Events and Holidays
Advertising & SEO
Supply Chain and Fulfillment
Prime Day
Brand Protection
Beauty Industry
Case Studies
Product Listings
Profit Margin